WHAT, WHEN and WHY of an Investigation

WHAT Warrants an Investigation – Fact Finding:

Investigations are often triggered by a resident, family or representative’s complaint or grievance OR an unwitnessed/witnessed occurrence.
The goal is to determine if maltreatment occurred and identify the root cause.

A concern/occurrence may include but not limited to: resident-to-resident altercations; falls; bruises; skin tears; sudden change in resident mood or behavior; equipment malfunction; not following care plan; staff neglect; suspicion of financial exploitation; observations of staff or resident misconduct (sexual, physical, emotional).

Maltreatment Defined:

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) defines maltreatment as any act or failure to act that results in harm, potential harm, or threat of harm to a person. This can include abuse, neglect, exploitation, or any other form of mistreatment. Maltreatment can occur in various settings, including healthcare facilities, and can be perpetrated by caregivers, staff, or other individuals.

‍

WHEN

It’s essential to gather information as soon as possible from resident, staff, and others when an occurrence is reported.

‍

WHY

To identify details ASAP to determine if someone is endangered and to determine immediate action steps if necessary.

STEPS TO A THOROUGH INVESTIGATION

Step 1 – Protection

> Ensure resident is safe

> Remove the suspected offender ASAP

> Report to Administrator/Director of Nursing iImmediately

> Interview the resident and other residents potentially affected

> Interview the staff

Step 2 -Immediate Interviews

Time is of the essence to determine if the care plan was followed, if potential maltreatment occurred or if there was any resident neglect. Have preprinted interview forms in an easily recognizable folder or binder that explains the procedure for front line staff to gather initial facts.

> Did the resident show any changes in mood or behavior?

> Did the resident appear to be in pain or discomfort?

> Was the resident holding a body part?

> Did you notice any redness, bruising on any body part?

> Did you notice any type of swelling upon visualization?

> Was resident noted with an unusual appearance (disheveled, clothing not on correctly)?

> Any unusual mood or behavior(s) noted by family or visitors?

> Has the resident had recent lab work or procedure?

> Any signs or symptoms of infection (i.e., not eating, cough, respiratory sx, blood in urine, back/flank pain, lethargic)?

> Has the resident had a recent fall?

> Change in any medications?

> Any subjective/objective signs or symptoms of pain or discomfort?

> When was the last time toileted, last BM, complaints of nausea?

> Resident refusing food or fluids?

> Potential environmental considerations (temperature, wet floor, table height, floor mats, etc..)?

> Potential equipment issues – new use or potential issues, use of mechanical lift, wheelchair, walker, etc..?

> If the resident has a roommate, ask if roommate overheard or saw anything.

If there is potential for other residents being affected – interview a sample of residents on the unit to see if they feel safe, if their preferences are being honored, and do they feel they are being treated with dignity and respect.

Staff Interviews (A nurse (if on duty) should ask nurse aides questions regarding the residents.)

> Use a form for front line staff to complete, it is sometimes better to ask the staff to give their side of the story versus using preemptive questions that may not open further dialogue about facts that may help with the investigation.

> It may be necessary to call staff to get any insight from previous shifts.

> Ask open ended questions “tell me what happened”. Note date and time of interview.

Step 3 -The Interdisciplinary Team

> Facility leadership to determine if an initial report to OHFC/MAARC is needed.

> The IDT will have a start on investigation when interviews are performed immediately after identification of potential maltreatment or grievance concern.

> The team needs to meet ASAP to review the incident.

> Together the team will review ALL the information- review the interviews, what additional information needs to be obtained.

> Are additional calls to staff needed?  What additional staff and/or residents?

> Ensure that the person performing the interview signs and dates when documenting.

> Review if resident representative and provider were notified.

> Work with HR if staff were suspended pending investigation.

‍

Kris Ross, RN
Director of Clinical Services

For more information contact
consult@srcaresolutions.net

‍

Author: Michelle Stober RN, BSN
Michelle Stober, RN, BSN, is the CEO and Owner of Senior Care Solutions. With over 30 years of healthcare experience, her operational and compliance strategies have stabilized and protected more than 500 senior care organizations. She holds a Bachelor of Science in Nursing and specializes in clinical compliance and long-term care sustainability.

Read More:

Interim Director of Nursing (DON) for Nursing Homes

A Director of Nursing vacancy can quickly affect every aspect of a nursing home's operations. Staff may feel uncertain, survey preparation can lose momentum, and clinical oversight becomes more challenging. An experienced interim Director of Nursing provides immediate leadership, stabilizes the nursing department, and helps maintain regulatory compliance while the organization recruits a permanent leader or supports a leader on leave. 

Director of Nursing Skills

The Director of Nursing (DON) is one of the most influential leadership positions in a nursing home. Beyond overseeing clinical operations, DONs are responsible for building high-performing teams, ensuring regulatory compliance, driving quality improvement, and fostering a culture centered on exceptional resident care. As post-acute and long-term care continue to evolve, today's nursing leaders must balance clinical expertise with strategic leadership and operational excellence.

What Are the Leadership Styles in Nursing?

Nursing leaders make decisions involving staffing, resident concerns, documentation, clinical follow-up, employee competency, and communication across departments. The approach used to direct a team often changes according to the urgency of the situation and the experience of the employees involved.

What Value Does an Interim Director of Nursing Bring to Your Facility?

Federal guidance requires a Medicare or Medicaid-certified nursing facility to designate a full-time RN as Director of Nursing unless an approved waiver applies. CMS defines full-time under this requirement as 40 or more hours each week. 

What Are the Typical Qualifications and Experience Required for a Traveling Director of Nursing Position?

A Traveling Director of Nursing provides temporary nursing leadership to skilled nursing facilities during periods of transition, such as a leadership vacancy, medical leave, recruitment period, organizational change, or other operational challenges.

What Does an Administrator Do in a Nursing Home?

A nursing home administrator oversees the daily management of a nursing home. The position involves staffing, budgets, policies, survey preparation, resident concerns, supplies, and coordination among departments.